Unanswered Questions: Four Dead in Ohio

neil young ohio kent state On May 4, 1970, members of the Ohio National Guard fired into a crowd of demonstrators at Kent State University.  The shots killed Allison Krause, Jeffrey Miller, Sandra Scheuer, and William Schroeder.

Nine other students were wounded, and those who were shot included students on their way to class. The exact events of that date are still in dispute, with some of those involved still seeking answers.

Events Leading to the Kent State Shootings

The anti-war demonstrations began days earlier after President Nixon announced on television on April 30 that U.S. forces had invaded Cambodia. Pres. Nixon presented the invasion as a defensive response meant to help end the Vietnam War. But students and demonstrators believed the announcement revealed the war was escalating and expanding.

Watch Pres. Nixon’s address in the video below.

The day after Nixon’s address, on May 1 students began demonstrating at Kent State University. After some confrontations between local police and demonstrators, Ohio Governor James Rhodes called out the National Guard.

On May 4, members of the Guard used tear gas to disperse protesters. And while the protesters were in retreat, suddenly over the course of 13 seconds, 67 bullets were fired, resulting in the deaths and injuries.

Questions About the Shootings

A big question remaining is whether or not someone gave an order to fire on the demonstrators. At a 2012 news conference, seven of the people who were wounded that day announced a campaign to convince officials to hold hearings on the question. They claimed that analysis of audio recordings shed new light on the question, apparently revealing that there was an order to fire.

The group sought public support for the government inquiries.  They said they did not seek individual prosecutions. Instead, they sought answers.   Those questions and answers are still relevant today, as addressed in an excellent essay by Jesse Kornbluth at Huffington Post.

But subsequently in 2012, the FBI concluded the new tapes were inconclusive.  The Department of Justice decided not to re-open the case. [2015 Update] Having failed to get the review they wanted in the U.S., the Kent State Truth Tribunal subsequently requested a review by the United Nations Human Rights Committee.

Neil Young’s “Ohio”

In 1970, the Kent State shootings became national news, affecting everyone who read about it, including a young songwriter. After seeing photos in Life magazine, Neil Young wrote the song “Ohio.”

Then, Young’s group Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young recorded the song only 11 days after the tragedy and then quickly released it as a single. Young later noted that David Crosby broke down and cried after the recording.

The video below for “Ohio” was put together by a talented YouTuber. Check it out.

“Ohio,” which first appeared on an album as a live song on Four Way Street (1971), stirred up some controversy for its criticism of Pres. Nixon.  But the song went on to become a classic. It has been covered by a number of artists, including the Isley Brothers on Givin’ It Back (1971).

Rolling Stone lists “Ohio” as the 365th greatest rock song of all time. The song deserves a spot in the rankings as there are few songs that were so immediate about a current event.  And there are few songs with such unanswered questions four decades after the song’s release.

Leave your two cents in the comments.

  • Crosby, Stills, Nash, Young & . . . Tom Jones?
  • Arlo McKinley’s “Die Midwestern” (Song of the Day)
  • October 1992: They Were So Much Older Then
  • The First Farm Aid
  • It’s “Rock & Roll Time” When Jerry Lee Lewis Releases New Music
  • Don McLean Live at Glastonbury
  • (Some Related Chimesfreedom Posts)

    Buy from Amazon