“The River” Had a Happy Ending After All

The River One of the many depressing songs on Bruce Springsteen’s 1980 double album The River, is the title track. The song ends with the singer haunted by memories, wondering “Is a dream a lie if it don’t come true / Or is it something worse?” The story is based on real life, but the real-life inspirations for the song did not have the ending foreseen in the lyrics.

“The River”

The singer of “The River” tells the story of meeting Mary in high school. The singer first recounts how the high school kids would go down to dive in the river. While the image is one of teenage joy, the music and earlier lines about growing up “to do like your daddy done” hint at something sadder. By the time the singer is nineteen, Mary is pregnant, and the couple find themselves getting married at the courthouse “with no wedding day smiles.”

In the song, more troubles come.  The singer faces hard times and acts like he no longer remembers the past.  Meanwhile, Mary “acts like she don’t care.” But the singer does remember the past.  And it is those good times at the river that haunt his days.

The Inspiration for “The River”

Springsteen based his song on his sister Virginia (“Ginny”), who during her senior year of high school became pregnant. Ginny married her boyfriend, Michael “Mickey” Shave, who was a rodeo rider, in a small ceremony. The two then began their young family life together.

In this video from one of his performances during the the No Nukes: The Muse Concerts For a Non-Nuclear Future on September 19-23, 1979 at Madison Square Garden, you can hear Springsteen introducing the new song with, “this is my brother-in-law and my sister.”

The Real-Life Story

Although Springsteen imagined a sad life resulting from such a start, things worked out better for Ginny and Mickey than they did for the singer and Mary. Ginny and Mickey have been married for more than forty years, and they had three children and several grandchildren.

While, like everyone, Ginny and Mickey may wonder some days about what might have been, the real-life people who inspired “The River” do not seem as haunted as the characters in the song.

Not only did things work out for the couple, but their wedding gave Ginny’s brother what Rolling Stone Magazine calls his fifth greatest song. It sounds like everyone’s dreams came true after all.

What do you think of “The River”? Leave your two cents in the comments.

Buy from Amazon

  • Bob Seger and Bruce Springsteen “Shout” In Their Third Performance Together
  • Bruce Springsteen: Always Roaming With a Hungry Heart
  • “New” Springsteen Track: “Meet Me In the City”
  • Passover: Moses and the Price You Pay
  • Bruce Springsteen’s Fighting Prayer for the U.S.
  • 10 Thoughts on Bruce Springsteen’s “Only the Strong Survive”
  • (Some related Chimesfreedom posts.)

    Springsteen & Family Rock Raleigh (Guest Post)

    Bruce Patti

    The following is a Guest Post by Brad Risinger, reporting on Thursday’s Bruce Springsteen concert in Raleigh, North Carolina.

    Bruce Springsteen’s April 24 Raleigh stop on the High Hopes (2014) tour was a family affair. Vocalist wife Patti Scialfa made the scene, along with daughter Jessica, who is a student at nearby Duke University. Little Steven — a blood brother if ever there was one — was missed, but the ensemble feel of this E Street iteration has a comfortable vibe that is less forced than the Seeger conglomeration and more at peace with the voids left by old friends Clarence Clemons and Danny Federici.

    The band’s sound is large on this tour, benefiting from a lot of layering and height provided by a blistering horn section which Jake Clemons helms and a gifted trio of back-up singers. I probably paid more attention to the latter than I usually would have after seeing the wonderful documentary 20 Feet From Stardom (2013) earlier this spring that centered around Darlene Love and a handful of should-be-famous back-up singers. Go queue up The Rolling Stones’ “Gimme Shelter,” turn up the sound and down the lights, and listen to what soars behind Mick Jagger. And then rent the movie.

    Tom Morello has been nicely enmeshed into the band, and it has produced interesting results. Springsteen opened with “High Hopes,” and featured a prominent role for Morello that could have set the stage for a tougher backbone to much of the night helmed by the former Rage Against The Machine guitarist. But as the band dealt with Little Steven’s departure and return, and incorporated Nils Lofgren’s lilting voice and tilting guitar, it has found a home for Morello that gets the best of some nasty shreds within the team concept. The “Ghost of Tom Joad” collaboration between Springsteen and Morello, which introduced the latter to E Street, continues to be a wicked piece that shines, but does not overstate its presence. Morello blended in for much of the evening, and was a foil for Springsteen in Van Zandt’s absence. Lofgren’s wild solo in “Because The Night” had a partner-in-crime feel to it, while Morello’s role is more like a younger, evil twin. It’s an interesting balancing act that could take some neat turns in the band’s new phase.

    Any band that forms, endures, separates and then charges back reinvents itself regularly. Clarence cannot be replaced, but his nephew Jake has carved his own space. He does not so much mimic the Big Man’s iconic turns on “The Promised Land” and “Thunder Road” as he does honor them. His spin through “Land of Hope and Dreams” feels authentic; it may not turn out to be his “Jungleland,” but it gives the audience confidence that Jake and Bruce will find it. The talented “Sister” Soozie Tyrell feels more lost in this band configuration, but she still has a couple of moments in the parts of the show that recall the Seeger Sessions feel. I would still like one chance to hear Tyrell reprise the string track from the “Incident on 57th Street” version at the February 1975 Main Point show. You may hear that version online; it is a WMMR simulcast that stands the test of time.

    Scialfa has always had an interesting role on E Street, and while she has not been steadily on the road in recent years, her voice is aging with her husband’s in a very complementary and intertwined kind of way. I have always liked her voice, and the tension it sometimes has lent the band. While she has had her critics among the Springsteen faithful, her Rumble Doll (1993) CD is a quirky, honest album worth a listen. And she plays off of Bruce in ways now that she didn’t a decade ago. “Brilliant Disguise” in their hands is rarely played but has become smoky over the years and more intimate. And she and Bruce ratchet over each other on “Because the Night” in a way that is angry and conciliatory at the same time. Let’s hope before Patti heads home some audience gets a tortured and understanding take of “One Step Up” sung with her man.

    E Street Band shows have always been a tactile experience; for years the curved catwalk behind the stage was a staple when the backshop seats were sold. And, then as now, “Dancing in the Dark” brings company to the stage. But Bruce’s audience roaming has become nomadic in a fun and personal way. Springsteen visited a walkway that sliced through the center of the arena floor a number of times, and it is a slower, more luxuriant trip these days. He stopped for fan selfies, perused the signs requesting songs, and he confidently flung himself into the crowd to be “surfed” back to the stage. It was a snaky looking path, to be sure, but he got there. It is impossible to declare that the band, or Springsteen himself, is having more fun than before. It is tempting to say Springsteen sees the end of the touring road coming at age 64 and is taking a long, reflective walk through his catalog for loyal fans. But honestly, the message he sends off is more celebratory than “so long.”

    Nobody gets everything, even in a three-hour rock show that never takes a break. But there is always an oddity that jumps up to surprise. On the Australia swing, a raucous “Highway to Hell” cover banged around on a few nights. And there’s no telling when you will get an “I Fought the Law” or “Summertime Blues” bar band moment. In Raleigh, Patti selected a bright, construction-paper pink flamingo from the crowd and asked Bruce to play “Pretty Flamingo,” a 1960s Manfred Mann hit that he has played only a handful of times over the years. Springsteen exhorted himself to “tell the story, Bruce” to set up the song, and had to reach a bit to find the lyrics and chords before diving in.

    These requests from the floor for rarities are a funny business. A fan came with an elaborate sign request for a song Bruce has not played in years, and only rarely ever. It reminds me of the story Bruce used to tell about the guy who followed him for years and held up a sign requesting “Murder, Incorporated” long before it became widely popular. Bruce said he never had any intention of playing it, but admired the persistence. But, some obsessive fan who had the song on a vinyl bootleg from the early 1980s kept requesting it and finally got it. I did not hold up the sign, but I wore that old record out in college.

    Springsteen called an early audible by picking a sign request for “Brilliant Disguise,” as a lead-in to “Atlantic City” and “Johnny 99.” The show’s Nebraska cameo was an eclectic, and interesting tempo and mood shift. “Atlantic City” had a minister’s desperation to it, less personal perhaps than the album version, but with a keen and softly spoken pulpit verse that resonated. “Johnny 99” was a treat, part Preservation Hall with the E Street Horns and part Roy Bittan rockabilly. (The horns were a good return jab at the recent, loopy comments from Courtney Love critical of the E Street Band because saxophones, she says, have no place in a real rock band.)

    I resist the “tape measure” crowd among E Street loyals that obsessively compares minutes on stage, tour premieres, and set lists as if they were Albert Pujols home runs. At just under two hours, 50 minutes and 26 songs, the show was a bit shorter than some recent 3-plus-hour, 30-song cycles, but it was outstanding nonetheless. Sure, there were songs missing — as there always are — but it was a show with lots of flair and personality even if some of the recent, off-beat set list appearances stayed in the drawer. “Wrecking Ball” has better wings now as a cog in the show rather than a centerpiece, and “Because the Night” growled its way through the audience following a nice, moody sign-request of “I’m on Fire.”

    It is fair to be jealous that Charlotte got “Louie Louie,” “Mustang Sally” and “Racing in the Street,” but “Pretty Flamingo” surely counts as a surprise, and a fun one at that. And Springsteen dressed up “Growin’ Up” for his daughter Jessica, who is graduating this spring and was in the pit with friends. She also made it on stage to twirl with her dad for “Dancing in the Dark” in a sweet moment. She seemed like a graceful kid, comfortable with dad’s stardom and with being onstage with the family.

    Check out Blogness on the Edge of Town for the full Raleigh setlist.

    What did you think of the Raleigh show? Leave your two cents in the comments.

  • Springsteen’s “Whoop-Ass Session on the Recession” in Greensboro (Guest Post)
  • Bruce and Patti at Home in the “Land of Hope and Dreams”
  • Fathers, Birth, and Rebirth In Springsteen Songs
  • Tougher Than the Rest
  • Springsteen Short Film for “Hunter of Invisible Game”
  • Springsteen Video for The Saints Cover “Just Like Fire Would”
  • (Some related Chimesfreedom posts.)

    Springsteen EP “American Beauty”

    American Beauty
    For Record Store Day, Bruce Springsteen has released a four-song EP called American Beauty. Two of the songs — “American Beauty” and “Hurry Up Sundown” — were extra tracks not used on his most recent album, High Hopes (2014). Another song, “Mary Mary,” was recorded at the time of Magic (2007), while “Hey Blue Eyes” was left over from the Working on a Dream (2009) recordings.

    You may listen to the rocking “Hurry Up Sundown” over at NPR. Below is the title track, “American Beauty.”

    The softer “Hey Blue Eyes,” which Tom Morello reportedly plans to cover, is below.

    American Beauty, on sale in vinyl form in record stores today, will be available for people without turntables on April 22. Meanwhile, Blogness on the Edge of Town reports on other Record Store Day releases, including a reissue of Billy Joel’s song “Say Goodbye to Hollywood” recorded by Ronnie Spector and the E Street Band.

    What do you think of the “new” Springsteen tracks? Leave your two cents in the comments.

  • Bruce Springsteen’s Fighting Prayer for the U.S.
  • 10 Thoughts on Bruce Springsteen’s “Only the Strong Survive”
  • Local News Coverage of Bruce Springsteen in 1978
  • Belgians Reach Out to Bruce Springsteen With “Waiting on a Sunny Day”
  • “Satan’s Jeweled Crown” & Bruce Springsteen (Cover of the Day)
  • I’ll See You In My Dreams: Goodbye 2020, Hello 2021
  • (Some related Chimesfreedom posts.)

    Anniversary of “The Grapes of Wrath”

    Grapes Wrath 75 John Steinbeck‘s novel The Grapes of Wrath was published on April 14, 1939. The book, which recounts the struggles of the tenant farmers Joad family moving from Oklahoma to California, went on to win the National Book Award and the Pulitzer Prize. It also helped Steinbeck win the Nobel Prize in Literature in 1962. Steinbeck’s book seeped into popular culture, aided by a great John Ford movie as well as songs.

    Less than a year after the novel’s publication, 20th Century Fox released John Ford’s vision of The Grapes of Wrath in January 1940. The film starred Henry Fonda, Jane Darwell, and John Carradine, and it contained some differences from the book, and in particular the ending.

    While the book was written as an indictment of the greed that led to the Great Depression, the conservative Ford maintained some elements of that vision while also giving the story a somewhat more optimistic ending. The Grapes of Wrath thus became one of those instances where a novel and its movie version both attained greatness even with some significant differences.

    The film would go on to inspire others. In particular, the speech by Tom Joad (Fonda) would inspire both Woody Guthrie and Bruce Springsteen to write songs. Check out our post about the story behind Guthrie’s “Tom Joad,” a song written at the request of a record company during an all-night session after Pete Seeger helped Guthrie find a typewriter.

    Bruce Springsteen used his stark “The Ghost of Tom Joad” as the title track of his somber 1995 album. In 2014, though, he released a new version of the song on High Hopes that features the raging angry guitar of Tom Morello, highlighting the defiance in Tom Joad’s speech. While Springsteen’s original acoustic version captures the sadness of the novel, his rock version of the song might be more comparable to John Ford’s vision. Check out this performance featuring Springsteen, Morello, and the E Street Band from Allphones Area in Sydney, Australia from March 2013.

    What is your favorite version of “The Grapes of Wrath”? Leave your two cents in the comments.

  • Tom Joad’s Inspiration
  • Mumford & Sons Join Elvis Costello on “Ghost of Tom Joad”
  • The Heroic Death of Folksinger Victor Jara
  • Watch Night, Emancipation, and “Mary Don’t You Weep”
  • Tell Me, What Were Their Names?
  • The Killing of “Two Good Men”
  • (Some related Chimesfreedom posts.)

    Springsteen’s “Spill the Wine”: Is This Just a Dream?

    Bruce Springsteen fans have noted that the singer has been making some interesting song choices on his latest tour. Recently, a friend directed me to Springsteen’s February performance of “Spill the Wine,” originally a 1970 hit for Eric Burdon (the former lead singer of The Animals) and War on their album Eric Burdon Declares “War” (1970). This February 23 opening performance at the Hope Estate Winery in the Hunter Valley of New South Wales, Australia was the first public performance of the song by Springsteen and the E Street Band. I am not sure there is a better song to open a show at a winery.

    “Spill the Wine” is one of those songs you have heard a million times even if you may not recognize the song’s name. The tune often appears in movies set in the 1970s, like Boogie Nights (1997) and Remember the Titans (2000), because the song sounds like the 1970s. You will recognize it once you hear the opening riff. It’s a cool song too, and Springsteen does it justice (with some lyric changes for the Australian locale), here leading into his own song, “Seeds.” Check it out.

    “Seeds” is about a family struggling to survive in the Southwest. As for “Spill the Wind,” you may read the different theories about the song’s meaning around the Internet. AllMusic, which gives its own interpretation of the song, notes that the song is so unique that few folks — like Springsteen and the Isley Brothers — have ever covered it. And, like a number of other one-off songs performed by Springsteen, so far he has only performed it once.

    Although Springsteen’s performance is a lot of fun, it is of course impossible to top the original. The first album of two collaborations between Burdon and War created this song that became War’s first major hit and Burdon’s last. Watch this performance by Eric Burdon and War of the shaggy dog story, “Spill the Wine.”

    What do you think? Leave your two cents in the comments.

  • Bob Seger and Bruce Springsteen “Shout” In Their Third Performance Together
  • Don’t Let (Badlands) Be Misunderstood
  • Bruce Springsteen’s Fighting Prayer for the U.S.
  • 10 Thoughts on Bruce Springsteen’s “Only the Strong Survive”
  • Local News Coverage of Bruce Springsteen in 1978
  • Belgians Reach Out to Bruce Springsteen With “Waiting on a Sunny Day”
  • (Some related Chimesfreedom posts.)