First Use of Electric Chair & Eric Church’s “Lightning”

Eric Church’s song “Lightning” captures a lot about the death penalty but his video gets one big thing wrong, missing the odds against Texas executing a white man for killing a black man.

On August 6 in 1890, the State of New York executed William Kemmler in the nation’s first use of the electric chair. As explained in Richard Moran’s Executioner’s Current: Thomas Edison, George Westinghouse, and the Invention of the Electric Chair, as New York prepared to execute William Kemmler, corporate interests and profit motives affected the debate about the execution method.

Edison vs. Westinghouse

Electric chair

George Westinghouse, who was working to make alternating current the U.S. standard for distributing electricity into homes, supported Kemmler in his appeals. Meanwhile, Thomas Edison, who was working to make direct current the standard, was an advocate for the electric chair.

Edison hoped that once people saw the use of the electric chair, they would realize that Westinghouse’s AC current was dangerous and adopt his DC current. As part of his campaign, Edison even showed how electricity could kill an elephant. Edison’s promotion helped lead to the state using AC current for the execution.

But in the long term, Edison did not win the DC-AC debate.  Today we use AC current in our homes.

Kemmler’s Execution

Kemmler had been sentenced to death for killing his common law wife with a hatchet.  After officials strapped him into the chair, the electricity was applied for several seconds.  During that time, Kemmler strained against the leather straps.

When attending doctors thought Kemmler was dead, the warden had the electricity turned off. But Kemmler’s body continued to twitch, causing observers to faint.

After doctors confirmed Kemmler was still breathing, the executioner sent 2,000 volts through Kemmler’s body.  Kemmler’s mouth foamed and blood vessels ruptured.  Witnesses smelled burning flesh as Kemmler’s body caught fire.

After the electricity ceased, Kemmler’s body went limp.  Doctors confirmed that this time Kemmler was dead. Following the execution, about twenty newspapers in New York called for a repeal of the law that allowed execution by electrocution.

Debates about the method of execution will continue as long as the U.S. is in the minority of countries in the world that maintain the death penalty. Recently, news stories have focused on problems with the chemicals used in lethal injection.

Eric Church’s “Lightening”

A slang term for being killed in the electric chair is “riding the lightning.” Country singer Eric Church incorporated the reference in his song, “Lightning,” about a death row inmate.

There is something about the imminence of death that makes a death row inmate’s perspective compelling for a country song. Reportedly, this death penalty song earned Church his recording contract.

Church’s song does not take a position for or against the death penalty.  But it focuses on the often overlooked families of both the condemned and the victim.

I like the version of the song used in the video more than the version from his debut album, Sinners Like Me (2006). The video version changes the sound of the inmate’s voice at the end in a way that the album version does not, using an old microphone sound to convey a timeless voice from beyond the grave. It’s a good and haunting song and video.

Yeah, tonight I ride the lightning
To my final restin’ place.

One aspect of the video, however, is somewhat inaccurate. The condemned in the video is a white man executed in Texas where the victim appears to be African-American. Although Texas leads the country in executions, that racial combination is exceedingly rare.

In 2011, Texas executed Lee Taylor for murdering an African-American inmate while serving a life sentence. That was only the second time out of almost 500 executions during the modern death penalty era (since 1976) that Texas executed a white person for killing a black person. The rarity is not limited to Texas, as a number of studies from various states show that one is more likely to get the death penalty for killing a white person than for killing a person of any other race.

  • “Nebraska” and the Death Penalty
  • Dylan’s “Julius & Ethel”
  • The Journey of “Hang Me, Oh Hang Me” From the Scaffold to the Screen
  • The End of Maryland’s Death Penalty and “Green, Green Grass of Home”
  • The Killing of “Two Good Men”
  • Bono and Glen Hansard: The Auld Triangle
  • (Some Related Chimesfreedom Posts)

    Buy from Amazon

    Louis Armstrong Born

    Definitive Louis Armstrong On August 4, 1901, the world was graced with the birth of one of the great musical geniuses, Louis Daniel Armstrong. Armstrong, who was born in New Orleans, often said he was born on the Fourth of July, although his actual birth date was August 4. Either way, we should still have fireworks on his birthday. Just as July 4 is seen as the birth date of our country, one might easily say that August 4 is the birth date of American music.

    Below is one of my favorite Louis Armstrong recordings, “West End Blues.” This perfect song was recorded in 1928 by Louis Armstrong and His Hot Five when Armstrong was in his late 20s.

    The “West End” in the title refers to an area with night life on the shore of Lake Pontchartrain in New Orleans. The jazz classic appears on various CDs, including Complete Hot Five & Hot Seven Recordings. The following video provides some interesting information about what you are hearing as you listen to the song. Enjoy. Happy birthday Pops.

    What is your favorite Louis Armstrong recording? Leave a comment.

  • Barbara Dane’s Cool Musical Legacy: “Wild Woman,” “Gasser,” “Hard-Hitter”
  • Louis Armstrong’s Genius and “West End Blues”
  • Happy Birthday Eleanora Fagan (i.e., Billie Holiday)!
  • Amythyst Kiah: “Wary + Strange” (Short Review)
  • The World Needs a Little Louis Armstrong Right About Now
  • Louis Armstrong and Jimmie Rodgers: “Blue Yodel 9” (Duet of the Day)
  • (Some Related Chimesfreedom Posts)

    D.B. Cooper and Todd Snider

    On November 24, 1971, a man using the alias “Dan Cooper” boarded an airplane in Portland, later claiming he had a bomb and demanding money before he disappeared forever after parachuting out of the airplane.

    In 2011, Newspapers reported that the F.B.I. had a “credible” lead in the mysterious case of D.B. Cooper. Once again, though, authorities remained baffled about the identity and fate of the famous hijacker.

    Although I was around when Cooper disappeared, my interest in him peaked with a great song about the hijacker by Todd Snider.

    The Hijacking
    DB Cooper
    FBI Composite Sketch of “Cooper”

    On November 24, 1971 — the afternoon before Thanksgiving — a man boarded a flight in Portland, Oregon under the alias “Dan Cooper.” The name was later misreported into legend as “D.B. Cooper.”

    On the flight, Cooper handed a note to a flight attendant.  In the note, he claimed he had a bomb and asked for parachutes and $200,000 in twenty-dollar bills.

    At a stop at the Seattle-Tacoma airport, officials met the demands, and Cooper released the passengers. After refueling, the plane once again took off with Cooper and the crew on board. At some point during the flight, Cooper apparently opened a door.  Then, he parachuted out of the plane with the cash into the night and a raging storm.

    Cooper was never found, and in later years various discoveries contributed to the puzzle. For example, in 1980, a boy found some packets of the ransom money on the banks of the Columbia River near Vancouver, Washington. Through the years, other findings have often raised speculations.  But usually it would turn out the evidence was not connected to the hijacking.

    In 2011, reports indicate that the F.B.I. identified a suspect in the case, although he is now dead. They are doing further investigation, so we will have to wait and see whether there is a real breakthrough or just another false lead like all the others.

    June 2016 Update:  In June 2016, the FBI closed the case on the hijacking, leaving the mystery of D.B. Cooper unsolved.

    Todd Snider’s Song

    Todd Snider The best thing about the Cooper news is that it gives me a chance to post one of my favorite Todd Snider songs, aptly named “D.B. Cooper.” Todd Snider is a singer-songwriter who tells great stories with his songs. Snider has noted that one of his greatest influences is Ramblin’ Jack Elliott, and it shows in his music and presentation.

    A Washington Post recent review of Snider’s latest live CD, Todd Snider Live: The Storyteller, explains that Snider may be “the most likable man in music.” The article reports that Snider is “one hell of a performer, having built up a cult following thanks to nearly 20 years of concerts that double as side-splitting storytelling sessions.”

    Snider’s song “D.B. Cooper” from the CD Happy to Be Here (2000) recounts the story of D.B. Cooper fairly accurately.  He does combine a bit of poetic license and childhood memory to make the tale an excellent song.

    In writing the song, Snider perhaps found a small connection to D.B. Cooper, who began his strange journey at an airport in Portland, Oregon.  On October 11, 1966, Snider was born in Portland.

    And perhaps because the hijacking occurred in the 1970s and the song was released prior to the events of 9/11, one accepts the tradition of making the outlaw a hero a little bit more than we might have at another time. “Not far away from the City of Roses / A light shined from a house out in the rain / It was D.B. Cooper / Drinking champagne.”


    You may hear the original full-band version from the album at this link.

    What do you think happened to the real D.B. Cooper? What is your favorite Todd Snider song? Leave a comment.

  • Well, Here We Go Again
  • Picture Show Online Tribute to John Prine
  • Which “Beer Run” Song Came First?
  • Ramblin’ Jack and “Don’t Think Twice”
  • The Epic Beauty of Tom Russell’s “The Rose of Roscrae”
  • He said his name, Bojangles
  • (Some Related Chimesfreedom Posts)

    MTV Launched 30 Years Ago

    Thirty years ago this Monday, on August 1, 1981 just after midnight. MTV began with a countdown to a rocket launch, a narrator then announcing “Ladies and gentlemen, rock and roll,” and then an image of an astronaut planting the MTV flag on the moon. Then the network showed its first video, “Video Killed The Radio Star” by the Buggles.

    MTV I did not have cable at the time, and I do not remember that first broadcast. But I had three friends who shared an apartment.  And they paid for the essential cable, even though their apartment was so small they had to carve out three bedrooms from one room. So I was soon exposed to MTV while hanging out at their apartment.  Immediately, I was mesmerized by the new network devoted to music videos that matched my short attention span.

    During the first week of its broadcast, MTV only had about 80 videos. But musicians and record companies soon changed that by making more videos to market their music to fans through MTV.

    Today, as MTV has long left behind much of its music legacy to focus on shows like Jersey Shore.  So, I suspect that they probably play much less than 80 videos now.

    Most people remember that the first video on MTV was “Video Killed the Radio Star.” Do you remember the second video? It was Pat Benatar’s “You Better Run.”

    For more information, Today.com and HitFlix look back on thirty years of MTV.

    (Some Related Chimesfreedom Posts)

    Music You Might Have Missed: Chris Whitley

    Chris Whitley Dirt Floor

    Chris Whitley may be the singer with the most CDs in my collection who most of my friends have never heard of. His music covered a wide range of styles, varying from album to album, but much of it was steeped in the blues, as he was an incredible guitar player. He often used alternate tunings on his guitar, creating a unique sound that is difficult to match.

    Whitley was discovered by legendary producer Daniel Lanois, and a protege of Lanois produced Whitley’s first album, where you can hear Lanois’s influence. I bought Whitley’s Living With The Law (1991) on a cassette tape when I lived in Arizona, and I played the atmospheric songs every time I drove through the desolate painted desert in the northern part of the state. I especially love the opening title track and the second song, “Big Sky Country.”

    “Dirt Floor” is the title song from a solo album Whitley recorded in one day in a Vermont log cabin. The sound of the album Dirt Floor (1998) and the sparse title song contrast greatly with the sound of Whitley’s first album, but “Dirt Floor” finds its power in a dark place that hides in the blues.

    As you see above, Whitley is posing with a cigarette on the album cover of Dirt Floor. Seven years later, the title song “Dirt Floor” was posted on Whitley’s website when he died in 2005 from lung cancer at the young age of 45. Whitley, who was born on August 31 in 1960, left behind a daughter.

    “There’s a dirt floor underneath here / To receive us when changes fail./ May this shovel loose your trouble, /Let them fall away.”

    If you like the music, check out more of his work.

    What do you think of Chris Whitley’s music? Leave a comment.

  • Chris Whitley: “Firefighter”
  • Big Ol’ Jet Airliner & Paul Pena
  • Virginian Jake Kohn’s Young Soulful Voice Sounds Older Than the Hills in “Dreams”
  • Amythyst Kiah: “Wary + Strange” (Short Review)
  • Lonnie Johnson: “Another Night to Cry”
  • Barbara Dane’s Cool Musical Legacy: “Wild Woman,” “Gasser,” “Hard-Hitter”
  • (Some Related Chimesfreedom Posts)